OUR PODCAST
Baseball, a sport steeped in tradition, has undergone significant transformations over the years. From its humble beginnings to the modern game we know today, baseball has seen its fair share of unusual rules that have impacted the game’s dynamics. Here are ten fascinating examples of strange rules that have existed or currently exist in baseball, showcasing the game’s evolution and the creative ways fairness and gameplay have been regulated.
1. Batter’s Choice: High or Low Pitch (1867-1887)
In the late 19th century, batters had the unique ability to request a low or high pitch before each at-bat. This rule gave batters significant control over the pitches they would see, influencing hitting strategies and pitcher development during that era. Imagine a modern hitter dictating the strike zone to the pitcher.
2. Catching Fly Balls Off a Bounce (Pre-1864) and Foul Balls (Pre-1883)
Initially, fielders could catch batted balls, fair or foul, after they had bounced once. This rule was a holdover from other games and helped players avoid catching hard balls with their bare hands before the advent of gloves. The eventual elimination of this rule for fair balls in 1864 and for foul balls in 1883 increased the importance of catching fly balls cleanly and changed defensive positioning and outfield play.
3. Flat Bats (1885-1893)
Concerned about low scoring in the National League, a rule was adopted allowing bats to have a flat face, similar to cricket bats. This change was intended to “juice offense” and did contribute to an increase in runs. However, the rule was eventually rescinded in 1893 because flat bats tended to splinter.
4. Walks as Hits (1887)
For a single season, walks were counted as base hits, dramatically affecting batting statistics. An astounding eleven players hit over .400 that year, but the statistics were later rewritten to correct this anomaly. This rule highlights a unique approach to valuing plate appearances and significantly skewed historical batting records.
5. Umpires’ Comfortable Seating (19th Century)
In the earlier days of baseball, umpires were often prominent members of the local community chosen before the game. They were provided with comfortable chairs near home plate, and players were expected to treat them with “utmost courtesy.” This reflects a vastly different perception of the umpire’s role and authority compared to the modern game.
6. Catchers’ Standing Position (Pre-Early 1900s)
Initially, catchers stood a few feet behind home plate, acting as a “glorified backstop.” The now-customary crouching position didn’t become widespread until the beginning of the 20th century. This significantly impacted the catcher’s defensive capabilities, pitch framing, and their involvement in throwing out baserunners.
7. Walk-Off Home Runs (Pre-1920)
Until 1920, a walk-off home run was only credited for the number of bases the winning run advanced. This rule diminished the impact and celebration of many game-ending home runs in the early decades of baseball.
8. Ground Rule Doubles as Home Runs (Pre-1930)
Any batted ball that bounced and went over the outfield fence was ruled a home run. This drastically affected home run totals and the understanding of what constituted a home run.
9. Lodged Balls in Umpire’s or Catcher’s Equipment
If a pitched ball becomes stuck in the umpire’s or catcher’s equipment, the runners are awarded a base. This rule ensures play continues fairly despite an unusual incident.
10. Unsportsmanlike Conduct by Fielders
If a fielder intentionally touches a fair batted ball with their cap, mask, or any other part of their uniform “detached from the proper place on his person,” all runners, including the batter, advance three bases. This rule penalizes unsportsmanlike conduct and aims to deter such actions.
These unusual rules demonstrate how baseball has evolved over time, with a focus on fairness, gameplay, and player safety. By understanding these quirky rules, we can appreciate the complexities and nuances of the game.